Latest News

Cressida Dick has resigned but the Met police’s problems are bigger than one person

Writer : Colin Rogers, Professor of Policing and Safety, College of South Wales

Metropolitan Police commissioner Cressida Dick has resigned after 5 years within the job. Regardless of successes similar to a lower within the total ranges of great harm to younger folks, and enormous numbers of harmful weapons being seized, her tenure has been stricken by a sequence of high-profile incidents of misconduct and felony offence by serving officers. These have all contributed to an more and more tense local weather in regards to the London police and, certainly, raised questions on Dick’s management skills.

Dick, the primary lady to steer the Met, stated it was clear that London mayor Sadiq Khan had no confidence in her management. Khan had beforehand requested Dick for a plan to “win again the belief and confidence” of the general public following numerous scandals.

Most notable was the horrendous homicide of Sarah Everard by PC Wayne Couzens and the police’s dealing with of subsequent vigils. One other two Met officers had been jailed for taking and sharing photos of murdered sisters Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman on the crime scene.

Constant allegations relating to institutional corruption and canopy ups, together with these surrounding the homicide of Daniel Morgan in 1987, haven’t helped her place. Dick is alleged to have initially refused to grant an investigating panel entry to police information techniques within the Morgan case when she was Assistant Commissioner on the Met.

Extra not too long ago, the Met’s preliminary reluctance to analyze alleged events at Downing Road in breach of COVID laws might have had some affect in political quarters, whereas a dangerous report into the tradition amongst officers largely based mostly at Charing Cross police station has additionally added to the criticism.

Every single day, hundreds of cops carry out their function with the utmost moral {and professional} method. Even so, most police forces comprise some people who interact in wrongdoing of 1 kind or one other. Whereas these allegations and incidents want accountability and investigating, finally the particular person in control of an organisation should bear at the very least some accountability for the actions of its members.

A woman is flanked by five police officers as she is arrested.
The policing of the Sarah Everard vigil grew to become a flashpoint.

Learning historical past ought to permit us to study from its errors. Sadly, the Met police has a historical past of main corruption and high-profile scandals. Allegations of corruption dogged vice squad officers within the 1960s and within the 1980s. The Scarman report highlighted issues between police and ethnic minority communities. Most famously, the MacPherson report in 1999 recognized institutional racism within the police following the homicide of London teenager Stephen Lawrence.

Organisational tradition

Maybe there’s a larger query right here – one in regards to the construction of the Met itself. It’s well-known that an organisation’s tradition will be pushed and altered by a powerful management. Dick typically appeared to apologise to victims with out actually acknowledging that, on the core of her organisation, one thing was fallacious. This doubtlessly signalled to these contained in the police tradition that there was no want to vary.

The issue of creating positive police are accountable for his or her actions will not be a brand new one for any senior leaders in police organisations. Nevertheless, in comparison with most different forces in England and Wales, the Met is extraordinarily giant. It has a number of layers of administration and numerous totally different management roles.

As of January 2021, the Met employed almost 50,000 folks, together with over 33,000 cops. It is a large variety of folks for one commissioner to supervise. It meant that so as to drive ahead her imaginative and prescient for change, and sort out racism and different points, Dick needed to depend upon extra junior officers to share her imaginative and prescient and sort out inappropriate behaviour. That’s one thing virtually unattainable in such a big organisation.

One of many peculiarities of policing as an occupation is that a lot of it, particularly frontline work, is carried out with out supervision and depends upon the moral resolution making of particular person officers. The chance inside such a big organisation for misconduct is gigantic and, in lots of circumstances, undetectable.

As well as, the police subculture is a really sturdy and resistant one. It depends on cooperation between officers of various ranks and encourages a notion of an “us towards the world” mentality – sometimes called the “skinny blue line” that defends civil society from anarchy.

The construction of policing presently signifies that junior and senior leaders are primarily promoted by way of the ranks, and thus are uncovered to this tradition all through their profession. It shouldn’t be shocking due to this fact that this tradition might affect resolution making.

Clearly, the CEO (for that’s, in actuality, what the commissioner of the Metropolitan Police is) of a big organisation has to reply for the way in which during which that organisation carries out its features. Typically talking, the CEO also needs to be instrumental in forming and altering an organisations tradition and attitudes.

Dick has acknowledged as a lot and, on this respect, joins different commissioners similar to David McNee (1977-1982), Robert Mark (1972-1977) and Ian Blair (2005-2008), all of whom recognized and tried to sort out corruption and criminality within the Metropolitan Police. The organisational construction, coupled with organisational resistance to vary, seems to have thwarted them each time.

Misconduct within the Met preceded Cressida Dick, and can lengthy outlast her. If something, the commissioner’s function in exercising management over police tradition and coping with ongoing allegations of misconduct is an unattainable mandate. Dick might have suffered the general public shame of removing from her job due to this, however whoever comes subsequent will face the identical problem.

What did you consider this text?
Nice | Good | Okay | Weak


The Conversation

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button